October 10,2024
Roy

The greatest difference between a ball and butterfly valves lies in their design and flow control mechanism.

A ball valve uses a spherical ball with a hole through its center to control flow — providing a full, unobstructed passage when open and a tight seal when closed. 

In contrast, a butterfly valve uses a rotating disc that partially obstructs the flow even when fully open, resulting in a slight pressure drop. 

This difference in design also affects their applications: ball valves are ideal for high-pressure, tight shutoff situations, while butterfly valves are more compact and cost-effective for lower-pressure systems.

Understanding the differences between a ball valve and a butterfly valve is essential to ensure the right fit for your needs. 

This article provides a comprehensive comparison and explores when to use each valve type, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of both.

Key Differences of Ball Valves and Butterfly Valves

FeatureBall ValveButterfly Valve
DesignSpherical disk to control flowThe rotating disk positioned in the center of the pipe
SizeGenerally larger and bulkierSlim and compact
Operation90-degree rotation for full open/close positions90-degree rotation for fluid control
Sealing CapabilityProvides tight shutoff; minimal leakageModerate sealing; slight leakage possible
Pressure HandlingIdeal for high-pressure applicationsSuited for low to medium-pressure systems
Flow ControlFull flow capacity when fully openPartial obstruction of flow when open
CostMore expensiveGenerally cheaper
MaintenanceRequires less frequent maintenanceMaintenance might be needed more often
Common ApplicationsHigh-pressure systems, oil, and gasWater distribution, wastewater treatment

Which is Better, Butterfly Valve or Ball Valve?

The answer depends on the specific application. 

If you need a valve that can handle high-pressure fluids, has a tight shutoff, and requires minimal maintenance, a ball valve is a superior choice. 

However, if you prioritize compact design, and cost-effectiveness, and you are operating in lower-pressure environments, a butterfly valve may be more suitable.

What Are Ball Valves?

A ball valve is a quarter-turn valve that controls fluid flow using a pivoting, hollow, and perforated ball.

When the ball’s hole is aligned with the flow, the valve is fully open. 

When the ball is rotated 90 degrees, the valve is closed. 

Ball valves are known for providing a tight seal with minimal leakage, making them a go-to for systems requiring reliable shutoff.

When to Use a Ball Valve

Ball valves are most suitable for high-pressure applications where tight shutoff is required. 

They are commonly used in industries like oil and gas, petrochemicals, and manufacturing. 

If your system requires full flow with minimal pressure drop when the valve is open, a ball valve is the better choice.

What Are the Advantages of Ball Valves?

  • Tight Sealing: Ball valves are designed to offer tight shutoff with minimal to no leakage, even after extended periods of use.
  • Durability: Ball valves tend to have a longer service life due to their robust construction, especially in high-pressure environments.
  • Full Bore Flow: When fully open, ball valves allow the fluid to pass with little resistance, which makes them ideal for applications where maximum flow is necessary.
  • Low Maintenance: Due to their simple design and reliable performance, ball valves generally require less frequent maintenance compared to other valve types.

What Are the Disadvantages of Ball Valves?

  • Cost: Ball valves are generally more expensive than butterfly valves due to their more complex design and materials.
  • Size and Weight: Ball valves tend to be bulkier, which can be an issue in systems with space constraints.
  • Not Ideal for Throttling: While ball valves can be used for on/off control, they are not recommended for applications that require precise throttling.

What Are Butterfly Valves?

A butterfly valve consists of a circular disc or vane that is mounted on a rotating shaft. 

When the valve is closed, the disc obstructs the flow.

When open, the disc is rotated 90 degrees to allow fluid to pass. 

Butterfly valves are lighter and more compact than ball valves, making them easier to install in tight spaces.

When to Use a Butterfly Valve

Butterfly valves are ideal for applications requiring a cost-effective solution for managing low-pressure fluids. 

They are widely used in water distribution, wastewater treatment, and HVAC systems, where moderate flow control and compact design are needed.

What is the Main Advantage of a Butterfly Valve?

The main advantage of a butterfly valve is its compact design and lightweight construction. This makes installation simpler, especially in confined spaces. 

Butterfly valves are also more affordable than ball valves, making them a popular choice for lower-pressure systems.

What is the Main Disadvantage of Butterfly Valves?

One of the main disadvantages of butterfly valves is that they cannot provide the same tight shutoff as ball valves, which means that some leakage may occur. 

Additionally, because the disc remains in the flow path even when fully open, they can create a slight pressure drop in the system.

More FAQs About Ball Valves and Butterfly Valves

What Are Butterfly Valves Good For?

Butterfly valves are best for systems that require moderate flow control and are operating at low to medium pressures. 

They are frequently used in water distribution, HVAC, and wastewater treatment systems due to their compact design and affordability.

How Long Do Butterfly Valves Last?

The lifespan of a butterfly valve depends on the specific application and operating conditions, but in general, they can last between 5 and 10 years with proper maintenance. 

In well-maintained systems, they can perform reliably over an extended period, especially in low-pressure environments.

Do Butterfly Valves Restrict Flow?

Yes, butterfly valves partially obstruct flow even when fully open because the disc remains within the flow path. 

This creates a slight pressure drop, which might not be ideal for applications requiring full, unrestricted flow.

Why Do Butterfly Valves Leak?

Butterfly valves may leak due to improper sealing between the disc and the valve seat, which can be caused by wear and tear, poor maintenance, or damage to the valve components. 

Ensuring proper maintenance and regular inspections can minimize the risk of leakage.

LIANKE: Exploring Ball and Butterfly Valve Manufacturers

Lianke Valve Co., Ltd, a premier valve manufacturer founded in 1982, specializes in high-quality industrial valves, including both ball valves and butterfly valves.

Certified by API, CE, and ISO standards, Lianke offers a diverse product line designed for various industrial applications. 

As one of the leading butterfly valve manufacturers, Lianke ensures customer satisfaction through innovative designs, ample inventory, and global distribution. 

Whether you are looking for durable ball valves for high-pressure systems or cost-effective butterfly valves for fluid control, Lianke’s expertise and customer-first approach make it the ideal choice for industrial valve solutions.

Design & Manufacture Standard: HG/T3704, GB/T12237 API 6D

Normal Diameter: DN15~DN350 1/2”~14”

Normal Pressure: 1.0MPa 1.6MPa 150LB

Temperature Range: FEP:-29℃~120℃, PFA:-29℃~180℃, PTFE:-29℃~150℃

Applicable Medium: Hydrochloric acid, Nitric acid, Hydrofluoric acid, Liquid chlorine, Sulfuric acid, and Aqua regia.

Body Material: WCB CF8 CF3 CF8M CF3M

Resources:

Ball Valves vs. Butterfly Valves

Difference between Ball Valve and Butterfly Valve

5 Differences Between Ball Valve and Butterfly Valve

RECOMMENDED BLOG
November 06,2024
Roy
What Is Triple Offset Butterfly Valve? A Comprehensive Guide

Introduction Triple-offset butterfly valves are improved flow-control mechanisms that have three radial offsets for better sealing and efficiency while performing difficult operations. The design is friction-free, so it guarantees no leakage and high reliability for extreme pressures and temperatures. Lianke Valve, a foremost player in the industry, has modified this technology in its fluorine-lined butterfly […]

Read More
November 06,2024
Roy
What is an Air Pinch Valve with Flange?

Air pinch valves with flanged connections feature secure and easy installation, ensuring a tight seal in piping systems. They are designed for corrosion and abrasion resistance, making them ideal for handling abrasive and corrosive materials, while their quick operation and self-cleaning design reduce maintenance needs.  Compared to other valve types like butterfly or diaphragm valves, […]

Read More
November 06,2024
Roy
What is a Simplex Basket Strainer Used For?

A simplex basket strainer is a straightforward yet essential piece of equipment in many industries. It is designed to remove particles and impurities from liquids or gases within a pipeline. Often referred to as a strainer simplex, it plays a crucial role in ensuring the following: This article explores what a simplex basket strainer is, […]

Read More
October 21,2024
Roy
Understanding P&ID Valve Symbols: A Simplified Approach

Piping and Instrumentation Diagrams (P&ID) are essential tools for representing the process flow and control systems in industries such as oil and gas, chemical manufacturing, and water treatment.  They use standardized symbols to depict the various components, including valves, pipes, and instruments, which allows engineers to visualize and communicate how a system operates.  Among these […]

Read More
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT US
Contact Lianke +